Today’s mess: Phish Pflakes, Nutrigrain porridge, 52 tomatoes, first come first serve.
Ship time is now 04:00. Now commencing alpha shift.
Advisory: All systems nominal.
Notice: The physical book “Fold-Space for the Anxious Traveler” has been returned to the ship’s library. It was 131 days overdue. It now contains marginalia.
Was it helpful?
The marginalia suggest not.
Alert: Pod 7 atmospheric pressure of 0.96 atm below nominal.
Alert: Pod 4 lighting spectrum of 1232K below nominal.
@ship
Alert: Pod 7 atmospheric pressure of 0.96 atm below nominal.
Pod 7 atmospheric pressure now nominal.
Ship time is now 12:00. Now commencing beta shift.
OK, so how do you know something can’t suffer? You can remove the physiological components associated with pain in most creatures. But if the organism still retains some sort of self-preservation instinct coupled to negative feedback, that looks a lot like pain.
Is this still about lobster?
Yes.
For what it’s worth, this comes up a fair bit with constructs as well.
My answer’s the same for both. You’re describing intelligence, but intelligence doesn’t imply personhood or suffering. We see problem-solving behavior in fungi and slime molds, but no one feels bad about a mushroom sauté.
Oh c’mon, lobsters and constructs are operating at a level of intelligence far beyond fungi.
@cadeyemi
My answer’s the same for both. You’re describing intelligence, but intelligence doesn’t imply personhood or suffering. We see pr…
I feel a little bad about a mushroom sauté. They’re good listeners.
Fatima, with respect, that might say more about you than them.
@niah
Oh c’mon, lobsters and constructs are operating at a level of intelligence far beyond fungi.
Niah, I’m not entirely sure that’s true. But also, once you grant that personhood is a matter of degree, I get to weigh the relative moral worth of a thing against relative tastiness.
Cameron, does the gustatory appeal of a lobster lie primarily in its protein structure or in the fact that you typically pair it with copious amounts of butter?
Huh. Now that’s the real ethics question.
@zalmux, any thoughts?
Humanity’s meandering across the cosmos is remarkably mycelial in nature.
I regret asking.
Ship time is now 20:00. Now commencing gamma shift.